MINI Clubman trim comparison

2024 MINI Clubman Cooper S vs Cooper S ALL4

The 2024 MINI Clubman Cooper S ALL4 costs $2,100 more than the Cooper S ($36,150 vs $34,050). The lowest-priced versions differ in drivetrain (Cooper S FWD, Cooper S ALL4 AWD); the Cooper S is listed only with FWD and the Cooper S ALL4 is listed only with AWD. They also differ in combined fuel economy (Cooper S 29 MPG with FWD, Cooper S ALL4 27 MPG with AWD) and transmission (Cooper S 7-speed automated manual, Cooper S ALL4 8-speed shiftable automatic). Engine and horsepower are the same.

Cooper S vs Cooper S ALL4: what's different

2024 ClubmanCooper SCooper S ALL4
Starting MSRP$34,050$36,150
Engine2.0L I4 Turbo2.0L I4 Turbo
Horsepower189 hp189 hp
Fuel economy (EPA combined)29 MPG27 MPG
DrivetrainFWDAWD
Transmission7-speed automated manual8-speed shiftable automatic
  • Pick the Cooper S for $2,100 less to buy.
  • Pick the Cooper S ALL4 for AWD (the Cooper S is listed only with FWD).

Highlighted rows differ. Each trim is shown in its lowest-priced version; MSRP excludes destination and options. Fuel economy from EPA fueleconomy.gov; safety ratings from NHTSA and IIHS apply to the whole model. Data as of October 2026.

Cooper S ALL4 vs John Cooper Works ALL4 All 3 2024 Clubman trims compared Every Cooper S comparison in 2024 Every Cooper S ALL4 comparison in 2024

The short answer

The Cooper S ALL4 adds AWD instead of FWD. If you deal with winter roads or need traction off-pavement, that could be worth $2,100 by itself. If not, the Cooper S saves you the money.

The Cooper S is the cleaner fit if FWD already covers the job. The Cooper S ALL4 only earns the extra money when AWD is the reason you are shopping up.

If you are budgeting this move monthly, the jump from the Cooper S to the Cooper S ALL4 is about $37/month on a 60-month loan at 6.5% APR with 10% down. That works out to roughly $2,220 more by the time interest is counted. The real question is whether AWD changes your day-to-day use enough to justify paying above FWD.

Trim navigation

Lock one trim, change the other side, and move through exact pair pages without resetting back to the full lineup every time.

Compare another trim against Cooper S Cooper S stays locked on this side. Use this row to test the next trim up or down while keeping the exact pair page intact.
Cooper S ALL4 John Cooper Works ALL4
Lower-price trim
Starts at $34,050
VS
Higher-price trim
Starts at $36,150
Value Pick: Cooper S
→
Clear Upgrade: Cooper S ALL4

Who notices the difference

The higher trim starts to make more sense when extra traction matters for your weather, roads, or weekend use.

When both feel the same

Under the skin, the Cooper S and Cooper S ALL4 share the same wheelbase and body dimensions.

The upgrade math

You are paying $2,100 for 5 measurable differences, which works out to about $420 per change.

All-weather floor mats for the 2024 MINI Clubman Check prices on Amazon (paid link)

Every Difference, Side by Side

This is the full read behind the quick decision signals above: the complete hardware, comfort, and equipment story. 5 specification differences, 3 shared.

Drivetrain Biggest
Transmission
Cooper S7-speed automated manual
Cooper S ALL48-speed shiftable automatic
Fuel Economy
Cooper S29 MPG combined
Cooper S ALL427 MPG combined
Annual Fuel Cost
Cooper S$2,650/yr
Cooper S ALL4$2,850/yr
Curb Weight
Cooper S3,333 lbs
Cooper S ALL43,534 lbs

Full Specification Comparison

Specifications reflect available data as of October 2026. Confirm details with an authorized dealer before purchasing.

Spec Cooper S Cooper S ALL4
Pricing
MSRP$34,050$36,150
Powertrain
Engine2.0L I4 Turbo2.0L I4 Turbo
Horsepower189 hp189 hp
Torque206 lb-ft206 lb-ft
Transmission7-speed automated manual8-speed shiftable automatic
DrivetrainFWDAWD
Fuel Economy
City MPG2523
Highway MPG3532
Combined MPG2927
Fuel Tank13.2 gal13.2 gal
Annual Fuel Cost (EPA)$2,650/yr$2,850/yr
Dimensions
Curb Weight3,333 lbs3,534 lbs
Wheelbase105.1"105.1"
Length168.5"168.5"
Width70.9"70.9"
Height56.7"56.7"

Data sources: licensed third-party automotive data, EPA fueleconomy.gov, NHTSA, and official manufacturer materials. Values marked est. are estimated.

2024 MINI Clubman Cooper S vs Cooper S ALL4 Questions Shoppers Ask

Use this page for the direct trim answer, then zoom back out to the MINI Clubman lineup, the MINI brand hub, the Minivans, the how to pick a trim guide, or our mid-trim value research when you need the bigger shopping path behind this one matchup.

How much more does the 2024 Clubman Cooper S ALL4 cost than the Cooper S?

The Cooper S ALL4 starts at $36,150 compared to $34,050 for the Cooper S. That is a $2,100 difference, or approximately $37/month more on a 60-month loan.

Do the 2024 MINI Clubman Cooper S and Cooper S ALL4 have the same engine?

Yes. Both use the 2.0L I4 Turbo producing 189 hp and 206 lb-ft of torque. The engine hardware does not change between these trims, so the real differences are in equipment and feature content.

Do the 2024 Clubman Cooper S and Cooper S ALL4 use the same drivetrain?

Not in this comparison. The Cooper S is shown with FWD and the Cooper S ALL4 with AWD, which affects traction, fuel economy, and curb weight. If the Cooper S is also sold with AWD, that version is listed separately on the 2024 Clubman page with its own price.

Is the 2024 MINI Clubman Cooper S ALL4 worth $2,100 more than the Cooper S?

The $2,100 adds AWD. Worth it if you need the traction. Not worth it if you drive on dry roads year-round.

Which 2024 MINI Clubman trim gets better fuel economy, the Cooper S or the Cooper S ALL4?

The Cooper S is the more efficient of the two at 29 combined MPG, versus 27 for the other trim. That matters most if you are balancing running costs against the extra power, drivetrain, or comfort equipment tied to the pricier trim.

What $2,100 Gets You

The Clubman Cooper S ALL4 is a clear upgrade over the Cooper S. The $2,100 price increase gets you AWD and transmission -- real functional changes, not just cosmetics.

Cooper S vs. Cooper S ALL4: Day-to-Day

The Cooper S ALL4 has AWD while the Cooper S has FWD. This affects traction, weight, and fuel economy. The Cooper S uses a 7-speed automated manual; the Cooper S ALL4 uses an 8-speed shiftable automatic.

Fuel Economy Comparison

The Clubman Cooper S gets 2 more combined MPG. At $3.50/gallon and 12,000 miles/year, that saves roughly $108 per year or $540 over five years of ownership.

What Both Trims Share

Despite the differences above, the Cooper S and Cooper S ALL4 share engine, keeping the core Clubman experience consistent across trims.

Summary

The Clubman Cooper S ALL4 costs $2,100 more than the Cooper S (about $37/month more on a 60-month loan). That buys 5 meaningful changes at $420 per change. Whether that trade-off is worth it depends on which features matter to your daily driving.

Trim-Matched Accessories

These add-ons are split by trim intent so the recommendations follow the actual use case, not just the same repeated product block.

As an Amazon Associate, TrimAtlas earns from qualifying purchases.

Specifications shown combine licensed third-party automotive data with official manufacturer, EPA, and NHTSA source material for the 2024 model year. Actual pricing, features, and availability may vary by region and dealer. Always confirm details with an authorized dealer before making a purchase decision. TrimAtlas is not affiliated with MINI or any dealership.

Page updated 2026-11-14. Verify equipment, pricing, and regional availability with the manufacturer or dealer.

Keep Exploring

Official Sources & Methodology