2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD vs 2026 Toyota Highlander XLE
Full side-by-side comparison — pricing, performance, fuel economy, features, and safety. Updated 2026.
Full Spec Comparison
Highlander XLE starts at $43,390, $7,600 less. Model Y Long Range AWD leads with 115 MPG. Model Y Long Range AWD makes 350 hp (+107).
| Spec | 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD | 2026 Toyota Highlander XLE |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | ||
| MSRP | $50,990 +$7,600 | $43,390 Save $7,600 |
| Powertrain | ||
| Engine | Dual Motor EV | 2.5L Hybrid |
| Horsepower | 350 hp +107 hp | 243 hp 107 hp less |
| Torque | 375 lb-ft | 175 lb-ft |
| Transmission | 1-Speed | CVT |
| Drivetrain | AWD | AWD |
| Fuel Economy | ||
| City MPG | 123 +87 | 36 87 less |
| Hwy MPG | 106 +71 | 35 71 less |
| Combined MPG | 115 +79 | 36 79 less |
| Interior & Tech | ||
| Seats | 7 1 less | 8 +1 |
| Cargo | 68.0 cu ft | 16.0 cu ft |
| Screen | 15.4" | 12.3" |
| Wireless CarPlay | No | Yes |
| Heated Seats | Yes | Yes |
| Moonroof | Glass Roof | Yes |
| Dimensions | ||
| Curb Weight | 4,363 lbs | 4,370 lbs |
| Wheelbase | 113.8" | 112.2" |
| Length | 187.0" | 194.9" |
| Wheels | 19" Gemini | 18" Alloy |
| Safety | ||
| Safety Suite | Autopilot | TSS 3.0 |
Model Y Long Range AWD or Highlander XLE?
Both are competitive. Highlander XLE has a lower entry price, Model Y Long Range AWD leads on efficiency.Test drive both.
FAQ
What is the price difference between the 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD and 2026 Toyota Highlander XLE?
Which gets better gas mileage, the Model Y Long Range AWD or Highlander XLE?
Should I buy a 2026 Tesla Model Y or Toyota Highlander?
Which is more reliable, the Tesla Model Y or Toyota Highlander?
Is the Tesla Model Y bigger than the Toyota Highlander?
What is the cost of insurance for the Model Y Long Range AWD vs Highlander XLE?
What is the total cost of ownership for the 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD?
Who Should Choose the Model Y Long Range AWD
The 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD appeals to buyers who prioritize what Tesla does best: practicality and resale value. At $50,990, it positions itself as the more powerful option.
Fuel economy is a clear strength here — 115 combined MPG means lower running costs over the life of the vehicle. Tesla ownership comes with a distinct ownership proposition. Compare more: Model Y Standard vs Model Y Long Range AWD, Model Y Standard vs Model Y Performance, Model Y Long Range AWD vs Model Y Performance.
Who Should Choose the Highlander XLE
The 2026 Toyota Highlander XLE is the better fit for buyers who want a lower entry price.
Toyota's approach to this suv emphasizes long-term dependability and conservative engineering. If that aligns with your priorities, the Highlander XLE deserves serious consideration.
Why the Price Difference Exists
The $7,600 price gap reflects different brand strategies and equipment levels. The Model Y Long Range AWD is positioned higher, which is driven by significant differences in standard equipment, powertrain, or brand positioning.
Powertrain differences account for part of the gap — the Model Y Long Range AWD makes 107 more hp. Feature differences like a larger touchscreen, 107 more horsepower, larger wheels also contribute. Both are competitive within the suv market, and neither represents a poor value at their respective price points.
What Kind of Buyer Notices the Difference
Enthusiast drivers will feel the differences immediately if there's a powertrain gap. A 107 hp difference is noticeable during merging, passing, and hill climbs. Interior differences become apparent on longer trips where seat comfort, noise levels, and tech features matter more.
For buyers who primarily drive in urban and suburban settings under 40 mph, both of these suvs will feel remarkably similar in daily use. The differences surface on road trips, in extreme weather (where heated seats and AWD matter), and during technology-heavy interactions like navigation and phone integration.
When Both Suvs Feel the Same
In a parking lot, at a stoplight, or cruising in light traffic, these two vehicles deliver very similar experiences. Both are modern, safe suvs with contemporary safety suites, decent infotainment, and comfortable cabins. Neither will leave you feeling shortchanged in everyday scenarios.
The choice between Tesla and Toyota often comes down to brand loyalty, dealer experience, and which vehicle simply feels right during a test drive. We recommend driving both back-to-back on the same day — the subtle differences in steering feel, seat position, and visibility are more informative than any spec sheet.