2025 Subaru Legacy Sport vs 2025 Toyota Prius XLE

66 more hp and 10.0″ longer vs $4,615 less and 26 MPG better. That is the real fork. Key numbers: 260 vs 194 hp, 26 vs 52 MPG.

The short answer

The Legacy Sport leads on 66 more hp, 10.0″ longer. The Prius XLE leads on $4,615 less, 26 MPG better. The spec table compares 7 specifications head to head.

$4,615
Price Gap
66 HP
HP Diff
26 MPG
Efficiency Diff
Vehicle A
Starts at $36,410
VS
Vehicle B
Starts at $31,795

Key Differences at a Glance

Engine
2.4L flat 4 Turbo
vs
2.0L I4 hybrid
Horsepower
260 hp
vs
194 hp
Drivetrain
AWD
vs
FWD
Fuel Economy
26 MPG combined
vs
52 MPG combined
Annual Fuel Cost
$2,400/yr
vs
$1,200/yr

What's Actually Different

These two vehicles differ in 14 specifications.

MSRP
$36,410Legacy Sport
$31,795Prius XLE
Engine
2.4L flat 4 TurboLegacy Sport
2.0L I4 hybridPrius XLE
Horsepower
260 hpLegacy Sport
194 hpPrius XLE
Drivetrain
AWDLegacy Sport
FWDPrius XLE
City MPG
23Legacy Sport
52Prius XLE
Highway MPG
31Legacy Sport
52Prius XLE
Combined MPG
26Legacy Sport
52Prius XLE
Fuel Tank
18.5 galLegacy Sport
11.3 galPrius XLE
Annual Fuel Cost (EPA)
$2,400/yrLegacy Sport
$1,200/yrPrius XLE
Curb Weight
3,764 lbsLegacy Sport
3,164 lbsPrius XLE
Length
191.1"Legacy Sport
181.1"Prius XLE
Width
72.4"Legacy Sport
70.2"Prius XLE
Height
59.1"Legacy Sport
56.3"Prius XLE
Roadside Assistance
3yr/36kLegacy Sport
2yr/25kPrius XLE

Full Specification Comparison

Specifications and pricing reflect available data as of October 2026 and may not match current manufacturer figures. Always confirm details with an authorized dealer before making a purchase decision.

Spec2025 Subaru Legacy Sport2025 Toyota Prius XLE
Pricing
MSRP$36,410$31,795
Powertrain
Engine2.4L flat 4 Turbo2.0L I4 hybrid
Horsepower260 hp194 hp
Torque277 lb-ftNo published data
Transmissioncontinuously variable-speed automaticcontinuously variable-speed automatic
DrivetrainAWDFWD
Fuel Economy
City MPG2352
Highway MPG3152
Combined MPG2652
Fuel Tank18.5 gal11.3 gal
Annual Fuel Cost (EPA)$2,400/yr$1,200/yr
Dimensions
Curb Weight3,764 lbs3,164 lbs
Wheelbase108.3"108.3"
Length191.1"181.1"
Width72.4"70.2"
Height59.1"56.3"
Safety
NHTSA Overall5/5 stars5/5 stars
IIHS AwardNo published dataTSP+
Warranty
Bumper-to-Bumper3yr/36k3yr/36k
Powertrain5yr/60k5yr/60k
Corrosion5yr/unlimited5yr/unlimited
Roadside Assistance3yr/36k2yr/25k

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the price difference between the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport and 2025 Toyota Prius XLE?

The 2025 Toyota Prius XLE starts at $31,795, $4,615 less than the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport at $36,410. On a 60-month loan that is roughly $81/month. All prices are MSRP before destination and dealer fees.

Who should choose the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport?

The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport is the stronger pick when the extra 66 hp matters for your commute or driving style; you drive in snow, rain, or unpaved roads where AWD keeps you planted; you want the larger footprint for passengers or cargo.

Who should choose the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE?

The 2025 Toyota Prius XLE is the stronger pick when you want to keep $4,615 in your pocket and the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE covers your needs; lower running costs matter to you, roughly $807/year less on fuel; you prefer a smaller vehicle that is easier to park and maneuver.

Which gets better fuel economy, the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport or 2025 Toyota Prius XLE?

The 2025 Toyota Prius XLE rates 52 combined MPG, 26 MPG ahead.

Which is more powerful, the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport or 2025 Toyota Prius XLE?

The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport produces 260 hp, 66 more than the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE at 194 hp. The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport runs a 2.4L flat 4 Turbo; the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE uses a 2.0L I4 hybrid. Drivetrains differ too: AWD on the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport, FWD on the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE.

Is the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport bigger than the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE?

The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport is 10.0″ longer at 191.1″ vs 181.1″.

Do the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport and 2025 Toyota Prius XLE have the same drivetrain?

No. The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport comes with AWD, while the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE uses FWD. If you drive in snow, heavy rain, or on unpaved roads, the all-wheel or four-wheel drive option provides better traction. If you mostly drive on dry pavement, the two-wheel drive option saves fuel.

How do the warranties compare?

Both offer similar warranty coverage: 3yr/36k bumper-to-bumper and 5yr/60k powertrain.

Explore more: Subaru trims, Subaru Legacy trims, Toyota trims, Toyota Prius trims

Official sources

Legacy vs Prius: What This Matchup Is Really About

The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport and 2025 Toyota Prius XLE are both midsize sedans competing for the same buyer. Price, fuel economy, and daily comfort are the tie-breakers. The $4,615 gap adds up to $81/month on a 60-month loan. That is real money, so the pricier option needs to earn it with capabilities you will actually use.

Under the Hood

The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport runs a 2.4L flat 4 Turbo; the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE uses a 2.0L I4 hybrid. The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport has 66 more hp (260 vs 194). You will feel the difference merging, passing, and driving with a full car. The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport comes with AWD; the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE uses FWD. If you deal with snow, rain, or gravel roads, that traction advantage matters.

Running Costs: Legacy vs Prius

The 2025 Toyota Prius XLE saves roughly $807/year on fuel at $3.50/gallon and 12,000 annual miles. Over five years, that is $4,035.

How Each One Fits Your Daily Life

The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport is 10.0″ longer, which translates to more room inside but a larger footprint in parking lots and garages. The 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport weighs 600 lbs more. Heavier vehicles tend to feel more planted at highway speed but use more fuel and are harder to stop quickly.

Bottom Line

Choose the 2025 Subaru Legacy Sport when the extra 66 hp matters for your commute or driving style. Choose the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE when you want to keep $4,615 in your pocket and the 2025 Toyota Prius XLE covers your needs.

Specifications shown combine licensed third-party automotive data with official manufacturer, EPA, and NHTSA source material. Actual pricing, features, and availability may vary by region and dealer. Always confirm details with an authorized dealer before making a purchase decision. TrimAtlas is not affiliated with Subaru or Toyota or any dealership.

Keep Exploring